Competing Sunni Madhhab Rulings on Post-Adultery Marriage: Comparative Legal Reasoning
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.52496/mjhki.v4i2.155Keywords:
Zinā, Marriage Validity, Sunni Madhhabs, Comparative Legal Reasoning, TakhbībAbstract
This article examines why Sunni jurists derive different consequences for marriage following zinā despite their shared prohibition of the underlying conduct. It uses qualitative doctrinal research and a scenario-based comparison of selected Ḥanafī, Mālikī, Shāfiʿī, and Ḥanbalī texts. Contract validity, permission for intercourse, waiting or clearance, repentance, and lineage are treated as separate questions. Contemporary comparative legal scholarship informs the method, while a rules-and-standards perspective supplies a limited analytical vocabulary for institutional design. The findings challenge a simple permissive-versus-restrictive classification of schools. Al-Kāsānī records an internal Ḥanafī disagreement about contracting during illicit pregnancy; the Shāfiʿī passage examined does not impose a waiting period solely because of zinā; Mālikī material requires clearance; and Ibn Qudāmah combines waiting with repentance in the Ḥanbalī position he defends. A separate examination of takhbīb identifies disagreement within the Mālikī materials and a restrictive strand in Ḥanbalī literature, undermining its presentation as an exclusively Mālikī doctrine. The article proposes a consequence-specific typology linking factual trigger, legal consequence, justification, and evidentiary limits. Its novelty lies in this controlled reconstruction and the use of internal disagreements to test the typology. Indonesian marriage regulation is considered as a contextual application, not an empirical assessment of adjudication. The analysis supports precise attribution of school positions and cautions against turning moral condemnation or comparative policy arguments into ungrounded marriage impediments.
References
Abū Dāwūd, Sulaymān ibn al-Ashʿath. Sunan Abī Dāwūd. “Kitāb al-ṭalāq,” hadith 2175. https://sunnah.com/abudawud:2175.
al-Dusūqī, Muḥammad ibn Aḥmad. Ḥāshiyat al-Dusūqī ʿalā al-Sharḥ al-kabīr. Vol. 2. Islamweb digital edition. https://www.islamweb.net/ar/library/content/13/2137/.
Hallaq, Wael B. A History of Islamic Legal Theories: An Introduction to Sunnī Uṣūl al-Fiqh. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511801266.
Hallaq, Wael B. An Introduction to Islamic Law. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511801044.
Hutchinson, Terry, and Nigel Duncan. “Defining and Describing What We Do: Doctrinal Legal Research.” Deakin Law Review 17, no. 1 (2012): 83–119. https://doi.org/10.21153/dlr2012vol17no1art70.
Ibn Qudāmah, ʿAbd Allāh ibn Aḥmad. Al-Mughnī. Vol. 7. Islamweb digital edition. https://www.islamweb.net/ar/library/content/15/4682/.
Kamali, Mohammad Hashim. Principles of Islamic Jurisprudence. 3rd ed. Cambridge: Islamic Texts Society, 2003. https://its.org.uk/catalogue/principles-of-islamic-jurisprudence-paperback/.
Kaplow, Louis. “Rules versus Standards: An Economic Analysis.” Duke Law Journal 42, no. 3 (1992): 557–629. https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/dlj/vol42/iss3/2/.
al-Kāsānī, Abū Bakr ibn Masʿūd. Badāʾiʿ al-ṣanāʾiʿ fī tartīb al-sharāʾiʿ. Vol. 2. Islamweb digital edition. https://www.islamweb.net/ar/library/content/12/1170/.
Legrand, Pierre. “The Impossibility of ‘Legal Transplants.’” Maastricht Journal of European and Comparative Law 4, no. 2 (1997): 111–24. https://doi.org/10.1177/1023263X9700400202.
Al-Majmūʿ sharḥ al-Muhadhdhab. Later continuation associated with Muḥammad Najīb al-Muṭīʿī. Vol. 16. Dār al-Fikr, n.d. https://ablibrary.net/book_content/b/3943/242.
al-Mardāwī, ʿAlāʾ al-Dīn. Al-Inṣāf fī maʿrifat al-rājiḥ min al-khilāf. Vol. 8. Islamweb digital edition. https://islamweb.net/ar/library/content/26/4035/.
Michaels, Ralf. “The Functional Method of Comparative Law.” In The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Law, edited by Mathias Reimann and Reinhard Zimmermann, 339–82. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006. https://scholarship.law.duke.edu/faculty_scholarship/1249/.
Mustarsidin, Ahmad, and Akhmad Khisni. “Pregnancy Married in the Perspective of Four Madzhab and Compilation of Islamic Law (KHI).” Jurnal Daulat Hukum 1, no. 3 (2018): 699–704. https://doi.org/10.30659/jdh.v1i3.3370.
Oderkerk, Marieke. “Methods of Comparative Legal Research: How to Set Up and Carry Out a Comparative Legal Research Project.” In Uncovering European Private Law: A Student Handbook, edited by Marija Bartl, Laura Burgers, and Chantal Mak, 311–42. Cambridge: Open Book Publishers, 2025. https://doi.org/10.11647/OBP.0448.16.
Rachmadhani, Fajar, Mualimin Mochammad Sahid, and Muchammad Ichsan. “The Use of Sadd al-Dharī’ah in Contemporary Islamic Family Law in Indonesia: Concept and Practice.” Malaysian Journal of Syariah and Law 12, no. 1 (2024): 206–15. https://doi.org/10.33102/mjsl.vol12no1.505.
Republic of Indonesia. Kompilasi Hukum Islam. 1991. Text reproduced from the 2001 Department of Religious Affairs edition. https://jdih.usu.ac.id/id/regulasi/kompilasi-hukum-islam-khi.
Saḥnūn ibn Saʿīd. Al-Mudawwanah. Vol. 2. Islamweb digital edition. https://islamweb.net/ar/library/content/30/2084/.
Siems, Mathias. Comparative Law. 3rd ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2022. https://www.cambridge.org/highereducation/books/comparative-law/1CCBDFCE1ADB48DD34E56DB72E5D9022.
Van Hoecke, Mark. “Methodology of Comparative Legal Research.” Law and Method (2015): 1–35. https://doi.org/10.5553/REM/.000010.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Bambang Kuswanto, Oyo Sunaryo Mukhlas, Aden Rosadi, Dadang Syaripudin, Ahmad Burhanuddin (Author)

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.














